By Christian Berthelsen and Nicole Friedman 

Benchmark U.S. oil prices sank to a new four-year low on Tuesday amid signs of a lack of agreement among OPEC members on a need to cut production and shore up the market.

The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries is scheduled to meet in Vienna on Thursday to seek a consensus on whether and how to reduce output and stabilize prices, which have fallen more than 30% since mid-June amid growing global oil surplus. But signals sent by individual member nations thus far suggest there is little agreement on the matter, including how it would be achieved.

On Tuesday, member nations Saudi Arabia and Venezuela apparently held an impromptu meeting with nonmembers Mexico and Russia, but the group broke up without announcing any kind of proposal. Igor Sechin, head of Russian state oil company Rosneft, said that Russia couldn't immediately cut production anyway and that "the current price level isn't critical for us."

Oil futures had been treading water early in the trading session ahead of Thursday's meeting but dived after those developments. The U.S. contract for January settled down $1.69, or 2.2%, at $74.09 a barrel on the New York Mercantile Exchange, its lowest level since Sept. 21, 2010, while the global Brent contract for January fell $1.35, or 1.7%, to $78.33 a barrel on the ICE Futures Europe exchange.

"I think the market's taking that negatively as if there aren't going to be any production cutbacks from OPEC," said Andrew Lebow, a trader at Jefferies. "The market today is just growing somewhat anxious about whether there are going to be production cuts."

The market pared losses in midafternoon after The Wall Street Journal reported there may be preliminary agreement among member nations, including de facto leader Saudi Arabia, to more strictly enforce the existing production quota of 30 million barrels a day. Such a move could remove at least 300,000 barrels from the market based on recent data.

Still, it would fall short of the 1 million-barrel cut analysts say is necessary to stabilize the global supply-and-demand balance, and thorny questions remain about how the reduction would be apportioned among members and enforced. The market gave back gains as it faded into the close.

In the U.S. domestic market, traders are awaiting the latest weekly inventory data from the U.S. Energy Information Administration for a window into current U.S. supplies. Crude oil inventories are expected to fall by 100,000 barrels according to a survey of analysts by The Wall Street Journal, while gasoline inventories are expected to rise 1.1 million barrels, distillate inventories are expected to fall 900,000 barrels and refinery usage is expected to rise 0.4 percentage point to 91.6% of capacity.

In its own survey released late Tuesday, industry trade group American Petroleum Institute said crude stocks rose 2.8 million barrels, gasoline remained flat, distillates fell 1.3 million barrels and refinery usage rose 1.2 percentage points.

In refined product markets, December gasoline futures lost 0.16 cent per gallon, or 0.1%, to settle at $2.0318 a gallon on the Nymex. December heating oil lost 0.07 cent to settle at $2.3948 a gallon.

Benoît Faucon, Summer Said and Sarah Kent contributed to this article.

Write to Christian Berthelsen at christian.berthelsen@wsj.com

Subscribe to WSJ: http://online.wsj.com?mod=djnwires

US Oil and Gas (CE) (USOTC:USOPY)
Historical Stock Chart
From Apr 2024 to May 2024 Click Here for more US Oil and Gas (CE) Charts.
US Oil and Gas (CE) (USOTC:USOPY)
Historical Stock Chart
From May 2023 to May 2024 Click Here for more US Oil and Gas (CE) Charts.