50 Jewelers Say No To Buying Gold From Alaska Pebble Mine
November 02 2010 - 8:30PM
Dow Jones News
Jewelers from the U.K. and France have joined ranks with U.S.
jewelers such as Tiffany & Co. (TIF) to oppose the construction
of a large Alaskan gold and copper mine that could harm one of the
world's largest wild salmon habitats.
Fraser Hart, a leading U.K. independent jewelry retailer, and
Paris-based Boucheron have teamed up with John Hardy and Ingle
& Rhode to become the latest jewelers to sign a pledge not to
buy gold from the proposed Pebble mine in Alaska.
The Pebble project, which is located in southwest Alaska, is
jointly owned in equal measure by global diversified miner Anglo
American PLC (AAL.LN) and Canada-based Northern Dynasty Minerals
Ltd (NDM.T). Anglo-Australian miner Rio Tinto PLC (RIO) owns a
19.8% stake in Northern Dynasty while Mitsubishi Corp. (8058.TO)
owns an 11% stake in the miner.
There are now 50 signatories representing $5.75 billion in
jewelry sales who have signed the pledge. The signatories are
concerned that the Pebble project, one of the world's largest
undeveloped gold and copper deposits, will destroy an important
spawning habitat for wild sockeye salmon and jeopardize the
livelihood of over 5,500 people, according to Earthworks, one of
the groups campaigning against the mine.
The project hasn't been fully designed but it will likely
include an open-pit mine and possibly an underground mine that
could potentially produce 350,000 tons of copper annually and a
significant amount of gold and molybdenum by-products. The
projects' partners envisage such a project would require the
construction of waste-storage facilities, a deep water port,
possibly a power plant, and miles of roads and pipelines.
Earthworks expects the mine would produce 10 billion tons of
waste during the mine's lifetime based on initial resource
estimates from the partnership.
Anglo American has so far invested about $300 million in the
project and said it would commit $1.4 billion to take the project
through various stages of development but only if a mine could be
designed in accordance with Alaska's stringent environmental
standards and to the benefit of the local community.
"Our bottom line remains that, if the project cannot be designed
in a way that provides the proper protections for Alaska's
fisheries and wildlife, or to the livelihoods of Alaskan
communities, then it shouldn't be built," said John Parker, Anglo's
chairman, in April.
Anglo American believes that mining and fishing can co-exist in
the region and acknowledge that it would have to bear the burden to
prove it. A spokesperson for Northern Dynasty urged local
communities to wait for a development plan to be proposed before
commenting on the project's environmental impact.
The jewelers, Earthworks and the Bristol Bay Corporation, which
represents about 8,000 local shareholders, said the mine could harm
Bristol Bay's salmon industry, which supplies a third of the
world's commercial supply of wild sockeye salmon and generates an
average of $400 million a year.
"In Bristol Bay, we believe the extraordinary salmon fishery
clearly provides the best opportunity to benefit Southwestern
Alaskan communities in a sustainable way. For Tiffany &
Co.--and we believe for many of our fellow retail jewelers--this
means we must look to other places to responsibly source our gold,"
said Michael Kowalski, CEO of Tiffany & Co.
Jewelers consumed nearly half of the world's global annual gold
output last year.
But not all of Alaska's communities are opposed to the project.
Five of Alaska's 13 native corporations, which are located closest
to the Pebble project and represent the interests of local
communities, urged caution in jumping to conclusions before
evaluating the full scope of the project.
"We are disappointed in the actions by these groups and
organizations who have taken a stand against Pebble without seeking
the complete picture, especially without any consideration for our
perspective," the five corporations said in a letter to Anglo.
They mentioned that they would evaluate the project fully,
taking into account the project's impact on the fishing industry,
the environment and the region's high unemployment rate.
The Pebble partnership has hired an independent company to
facilitate dialogue with stakeholders about the review of
scientific data and any eventual mine proposal. It expects to
complete a pre-feasibility study in 2011.
-By Alex MacDonald, Dow Jones Newswires; 44 20 7842 9328;
alex.macdonald@dowjones.com
Northern Dynasty Minerals (AMEX:NAK)
Historical Stock Chart
From Mar 2024 to Apr 2024
Northern Dynasty Minerals (AMEX:NAK)
Historical Stock Chart
From Apr 2023 to Apr 2024