By Karen Talley
For most shoppers, the payroll tax increase will not cause a
stampede to lower end stores but may involve a more subtle
shift.
Middle-income consumers, a good chunk of U.S. shoppers, will
likely stick with their favorite stores, but they may buy less or
make fewer visits. Higher-end shoppers are unlikely to change their
shopping habits, but lower-income customers may be doing so
already.
The loss of the tax holiday as of the beginning of this year
takes about 2% out of payrolls. A person making $50,000, for
instance, would have roughly $1,000 less to spend annually. The
increase in payroll tax should lower total consumer spending by an
estimated 98 basis points this year, or close to 1%, Credit Suisse
estimates.
The loss is a far cry from the recession, when the lack of jobs
and job security sent shoppers to lower-end stores, as they tried
to make their money stretch as far as possible.
"This time employment, although not recovered, has improved, and
people are just tired of being frugal," said Craig Rowley, head of
retail for the Hay Group consulting firm. "They've enjoyed being
able to spend in the last year and won't easily give it up."
While the unemployment rate remains in the high single digits,
at 7.9%, it has recovered somewhat, which goes a long way toward
dictating what is spent and where.
"I don't believe most consumers are going to make really big
changes to shopping habits," said Edgar Dworsky, founder of
ConsumerWorld.org, a consumer information service. "People feel,
particularly if they have a job, they are doing better. I don't
think you have the pressure of the recession."
This suggests retailers that cater to the mid-market, like
Macy's Inc. (M) and Kohl's Corp. (KSS), and teen retailers like Gap
Inc. (GPS) and American Eagle Outfitters Inc. (AEO) could somewhat
deflect the brunt of higher payroll taxes.
At the same time, the stock market has been making new peaks, a
far cry from the days of the recession. Upper-end spending goes
hand-in-hand with stocks' performance, so the payroll tax should
have little negative impact on this demographic. This is positive
news for retailers like Saks Inc. (SKS) and Nordstrom Inc.
(JWN).
Lower-income consumers are the group that will be hit hardest,
because many already live paycheck-to-paycheck and now face even
more money coming out of their wages.
"This could have a lingering impact on spending, especially for
lower end retailers," Credit Suisse analyst Gary Balter said.
Wal-Mart Stores Inc. (WMT) already has demonstrated that the
payroll tax increase is having a negative impact, which it cited
last week as a deterrent to purchasing in a memo obtained by
Bloomberg.
Write to Karen Talley at karen.talley@dowjones.com
Subscribe to WSJ: http://online.wsj.com?mod=djnwires