By Viktoria Dendrinou and Valentina Pop
BRUSSELS -- A defiant Belgian region representing less than 1%
of the European Union's population has managed so far to halt a
trade deal with Canada supported by the rest of the bloc, raising
questions about Europe's ability to successfully negotiate complex
economic agreements.
Left-of-center politicians in Wallonia, the poorer, southern
region of Belgium, reacted with defiance and glee as they continued
to withhold their approval of the deal and put in doubt a summit
next week between the Canadian prime minister and top EU
officials.
The so-called Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement with
Canada, or CETA, has been hanging by a thread in recent weeks after
a revolt by Wallonia has been blocking the country's leadership
from supporting the deal.
Paul Magnette, the Walloon minister-president, said there had
been too little democratic debate over free trade and the negative
impacts of globalization. He told Walloon lawmakers Friday he has
nothing against Canada but wants to curb the power of corporations
in future EU trade agreements with the U.S. and other
countries.
He acknowledged that his region's parliament got to play this
role "by chance" and said that many in Europe likely regretted
granting it this power.
"But the moment we are given this power, it's logical we use
it," he said. While EU trade deals don't usually have to be
ratified by legislatures, the commission decided in July that the
38 national and regional parliaments across the bloc should get a
say on CETA. The move came in response to criticism from many
European capitals, including Berlin, that the step shouldn't be
decided only in Brussels, amid opposition against what critics said
were opaque deals the public had no say in.
After hours of talks with Mr. Magnette and EU officials on
Friday, Canada's trade minister said reaching a deal was
impossible.
"It is now evident to me, evident to Canada, that the EU is
incapable of reaching an agreement -- even with a country with
European values such as Canada, even with a country as nice and as
patient as Canada," said Chrystia Freeland, minister of
international trade.
EU Trade Chief Cecilia Malmstrom acknowledged talks with
Wallonia had been halted but said she still hoped to sign the trade
deal eventually.
At stake isn't only the deal with Canada but also the bloc's
reputation as a credible trading partner and its ability to
negotiate similar deals in the future, especially as talks with the
U.S. on a trade and investment pact are faltering.
Still, to revive the pact, the EU must solve its Belgium
problem.
Lawmakers in Wallonia insisted they are standing up for many
Europeans to demand a say on free trade and globalization. They
also have said they are worried the trade deal will have a negative
impact on the region's beef and pork farmers.
Frederic Gillot, a lawmaker from the far-left Belgian Workers'
Party, seemed to have dressed up for the combative occasion,
sporting a green army-style jacket and a dark scarf wrapped around
his neck.
"I don't think Wallonia is isolated, this is the same public
opinion in many countries," said the 54-year-old trade unionist
turned politician.
In 11th-hour talks, the European Commission, which negotiates
trade deals on behalf of EU governments, tried to reassure the
Walloon government. In a 10-page explanatory document reviewed by
The Wall Street Journal, it said that CETA "will not lower our
respective standards and regulations related to food safety,
product safety, consumer protection, health, environment or labor
protection."
But the peace offering was again rejected. Chief among remaining
concerns is a controversial court system to settle investment
disputes, which critics say would give greater powers to large
multinationals to sue EU governments.
EU officials are at a loss about what further incentives they
can offer Wallonia, given that much of the region's concerns have
been addressed over the past few days, while remaining complaints
seem to stem from a broader anti-globalization sentiment.
On Friday, only one Wallonian MP, Pierre-Yves Jeholet, spoke in
favor of CETA. He was continually heckled by his fellow lawmakers
throughout the debate.
Since the Wallonian rebellion began early this week, the Belgian
federal government has tried to put the best face on things, even
though they insisted they are powerless to override the regional
body.
"We can practically say that 27 and a-half-countries want to
move forward with the deal," CETA-supporting Belgian Foreign
Minister Didier Reynders said earlier in the week.
After that comment, his Twitter account was hacked and a tweet
appeared with a photo of former Canadian Prime Minister Stephen
Harper captioned with a nasty epithet.
The tweet was removed shortly afterward, and Mr. Reynders
tweeted a new photo featuring a red maple leaf and the message:
Keep calm and love Canada.
European diplomats say they were caught by surprise with
Wallonia's persistent defiance. In hindsight, said one, the signs
were everywhere in Francophone Brussels, just north of
Wallonia.
On dozens of traffic lights all around Brussels' European
quarter protesters have affixed stickers so that whenever the
signal turns red the words "Stop CETA" are visible.
"We should have seen it coming," said an EU diplomat. "No one
thought it could develop into such a deadlock in the final mile.
But it did."
--Paul Vieira in Ottawa contributed to this article.
Write to Viktoria Dendrinou at viktoria.dendrinou@wsj.com and
Valentina Pop at valentina.pop@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
October 21, 2016 15:19 ET (19:19 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2016 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.