Medtronic Study: Device Helps Epilepsy Patients Over Time
December 07 2009 - 12:08PM
Dow Jones News
A Medtronic Inc. (MDT) brain-stimulation device showed mounting
benefits over time by leading to fewer seizure episodes for
epilepsy patients, according to long-term results from a
company-funded study examining the technology.
The "deep-brain stimulation" system, which is targeted at
patients who have repeatedly failed drug treatments, could reach
the U.S. market in mid-2010. That would make Medtronic Inc. (MDT) a
competitor to smaller Cyberonics Inc. (CYBX).
Medtronic submitted an application to the Food and Drug
Administration in June seeking approval to market its system for
epilepsy backed by data released a year ago. The company is still
awaiting an FDA answer, and longer-term data from the same study,
released Sunday at the American Epilepsy Society's annual meeting
in Boston, could bolster the case with regulators and doctors.
A short-term benefit "would not be so useful for a procedure
that involved surgery and putting wires into the brain," said
Robert Fisher, director of the Stanford Epilepsy Center in
California and lead investigator on the "Sante" study.
Fisher does not have a financial relationship with
Medtronic.
The FDA recently delayed a planned November panel review for the
company's system, and that review likely won't happen until early
next year, William A. Hawkins, Medtronic's chief executive, said
during a recent earnings call. Medtronic still sees potential to
reach the market mid-year, however.
The study included 110 patients who had epilepsy for a long time
and weren't helped by at least three drugs. They were all implanted
with a pacemaker-like device that sits in the chest and sends
pulses to the brain by wires, but only half received power for the
first three months.
Patients receiving therapy showed benefits in terms of fewer
seizures compared with patients who had devices switched off.
Devices were turned on for all patients after this initial period,
and longer-term data showed a median 41% reduction at one year, 56%
at two years and 68% at three years, Medtronic said.
At the time of data analysis, 102 patients had completed two
years of therapy and 57 had competed three years, Medtronic said.
All patients continued to be managed with drugs.
This therapy carries potential for complications such as
infections around the power generator. Most of these complications
happened early, and "we haven't seen a signal of long-term side
effects that have emerged in years two and three after the initial
implantation," Fisher said.
Device-based epilepsy treatment is a relatively small market so
far, with Cyberonics, which has essentially owned that market for
the last decade, aiming for sales of $159 million to $162 million
in its current fiscal year. Cyberonics sees benefits from having a
heavyweight like Medtronic helping to expand the market.
"Having an additional player out there, a major credible player
like Medtronic out talking about neuromodulation for patients with
epilepsy, could be helpful," Daniel J. Moore, Cyberonics' president
and chief executive, said in an interview Friday.
He also believes Cyberonics' less-invasive system, which hooks
up to a major nerve in the neck, will be viewed as something to try
before doctors turn to brain surgery.
For Medtronic, epilepsy represents potential expansion for a
neuromodulation business that is helping offset slowed growth in
bigger cardiology markets. The neuromodulation business, where
treating Parkinson's disease is a key market, posted sales of $1.43
billion in Medtronic's last fiscal year, representing about 10% of
total sales.
-By Jon Kamp, Dow Jones Newswires; 617-654-6728;
jon.kamp@dowjones.com
Cyberonics (NASDAQ:CYBX)
Historical Stock Chart
From Mar 2024 to Apr 2024
Cyberonics (NASDAQ:CYBX)
Historical Stock Chart
From Apr 2023 to Apr 2024