By Josh Mitchell
The U.S. labor market snapped back to life in May, restoring a
chunk of the jobs it lost in the first two months of the
coronavirus pandemic, although big obstacles lie ahead.
After two months of carnage, employers added 2.5 million jobs
last month, the most jobs added in a single month on records dating
from 1948. The jobless rate fell to 13.3% from April's 14.7%, a
post-World War II high.
Employment remained down by nearly 20 million jobs, or 13%,
since February, the month before the pandemic prompted states to
shut down huge segments of their economies. By comparison, the U.S.
shed about 9 million jobs between December 2007 and February 2010,
a period that covered the recession caused by the financial
Hurdles remain in the effort to get more people back to work,
including the prospect of a second virus outbreak, pandemic-related
safety regulations and social unrest from the May 25 killing of
But the jobs report boosted hopes that the economy has moved
beyond the worst fallout from the pandemic and may recover more
quickly than expected. Stocks surged on the news, with the Dow
Jones Industrial Average climbing more than 3%, the S&P 500 up
nearly 3% and the Nasdaq heading toward a closing high.
"This is definitely in the right direction and suggests the U.S.
economy may be faring better than some of those worst-case
scenarios," said economist Lindsey M. Piegza of financial firm
Stifel Nicolaus & Co. "But it remains to be seen if this is
indicative of an ongoing positive trend or if this reflects the
bare minimum of the labor force needed to reopen the economy."
Economists still expect a slow and choppy recovery. Government
aid programs for households and businesses -- which have pumped
trillions of dollars into the economy -- will start to run out this
summer and fall. Many consumers and workers remain fearful of the
virus and are staying at home. And protests and looting following
the killing of Mr. Floyd, a black man who died in police custody in
Minneapolis, led many businesses to board up and close.
Still, a significant number of Americans appear ready to come
back to the marketplace, and businesses are eager to reopen to
accommodate them. Restaurants and bars added 1.4 million workers
last month -- more than half the overall job gain -- as new virus
infections eased and many states began lifting shutdown orders.
Other industries adding workers included construction, health care
and retailers -- among the industries that had been quickest to let
go of workers in March and April.
"The No. 1 customer call that comes in is not, 'Can I place an
order?' It's, 'Do you have dining?'" said Matt Friedman, chief
executive of Wing Zone, an Atlanta-based restaurant chain. In
recent weeks the company added five to 10 workers to each of its
two taverns in Georgia that recently reopened after being shut down
Mr. Friedman cautioned, however, that the two restaurants are
operating at far below capacity to comply with rules to prevent
further spread of the virus, including increased space between
tables. That will limit, for now, how fast he can rehire.
"It's almost like if you took a football team and put half the
players on the team on the field," he said.
Sung Won Sohn, an economist at Loyola Marymount University, said
the aid that Congress approved to help households is stoking
demand. While 21 million workers remained unemployed last month,
research suggests that more than half of those laid off during the
pandemic are earning more than they did at their jobs, thanks in
part to stimulus checks and extra $600 a week in unemployment pay
approved by Congress.
"People have been cooped up in houses and apartments for weeks
and they're anxious to get back," Mr. Sohn said. "They have money
to spend -- disposable income."
Despite last month's gains, the jobless rate is still
historically high -- nearly four times the rate in February. Jobs
remain down by 19.6 million from February.
The Labor Department also said its survey of households, which
determines the unemployment rate, showed a large number of workers
who said they were "employed but absent from work." The department
in a footnote on data-collection challenges because of the pandemic
said many of those people should have been counted as a temporary
layoff, which would have made the May unemployment rate higher by
about 3 percentage points. In April it said the same issue would
have caused the rate to be about 5 percentage points higher.
In May, a broader measure of unemployment -- including jobless
workers, those working part time and those who have given up the
job search because they are too discouraged -- stood at 21.2% in
May. Many other workers have taken pay cuts.
Gregory Daco, chief U.S. economist at Oxford Economics,
estimates that at least half of the workforce has lost a job, lost
hours or took a pay cut.
The jobless rate for Latinos was 17.6% and for African-Americans
16.8%, far higher than for Asians at 15% and whites at 12.4%. Women
were more likely to be unemployed than men.
In Portland, Ore., Kate Rafter had spent five weeks on a
furlough when she returned to work the first week of May at a
nonprofit that takes teens and adults on wilderness trips around
the Pacific Northwest. Two days after she returned, her boss told
her she was being laid off. Many parents had canceled plans to send
their children on trips given the risk of catching the virus. The
nonprofit said it could no longer afford to keep Ms. Rafter on as a
Now, she is living off unemployment benefits and the stimulus
check Congress provided to many households. She is hopeful, though,
because she has seen a number of job postings in her field. "I
think I'll be able to find something," she said. She has spent
recent weeks sewing hundreds of masks which she has donated and
decluttering her parents home.
There is at least one big sign that much of the economic damage
from the pandemic will be temporary: More than 80% of the people
who lost jobs during the pandemic expect the loss to be
Those permanently separated from their jobs totaled 3 million in
May, a low level compared with prior downturns. In October 2009,
when unemployment peaked after the financial crisis, there were 8.3
million such workers.
Manufacturers also are adding jobs. Tuff Shed Inc., a
Denver-based manufacturer of backyard storage sheds, has called
back the 500 employees it furloughed in late March, one-third of
its total workforce. The privately held company is now trying to
hire about 300 more employees for its 52 production sites as demand
surges for its prefabricated wooden buildings.
Tuff Shed's buildings are being used as makeshift offices and
home-school classrooms by families marooned in their homes by the
pandemic, said Phil Worth, the company's vice president of
marketing. The most popular office shed measures 10 feet by 12
feet, about the size of a bedroom, with prices starting at about
Tuff Shed's May sales were up 26% from a year earlier and soared
90% from April, Mr. Worth said. Home Depot accounts for about half
of its sales.
"The amount of demand is shocking," he said. "We definitely want
to add production capacity. People don't want to wait a long time
once they've made a decision to buy a building."
Nearly 90% of Fiat Chrysler Automobiles NV's hourly factory
workforce in North America has returned to work, the company said.
Fiat Chrysler and its U.S. competitors General Motors Co. and Ford
Motor Co. restarted factory work in North America on May 18 and
have since been ramping up production.
Job postings rose in the past week by 10%, according to an
analysis of internal data by ManpowerGroup North America, a
job-placement company. Some of the highest demand is for workers in
information technology, including for software developers, said
Becky Frankiewicz, the group's president. She suspects that is
because many businesses are now using apps for delivery services,
or software such as Zoom to hold virtual meetings. "As states start
to reopen we're seeing an increase in demand, " she said. "When
will we be back? We got here overnight. We won't return
Friday's report, based on a survey of households and businesses
in mid-May, offered a snapshot of the labor market before protests
and looting after the death of Mr. Floyd.
Penn Quarter Sports Tavern in Washington, D.C., laid off all 28
employees in early March after city leaders ordered nonessential
businesses to close during the pandemic. When the city began the
first phase of reopening last month, the restaurant rehired about
half of its employees in the hopes of reopening the bar this week,
said owner Mike Brand.
But protests and looting prompted him to board up his business
and delay the opening by at least a week.
"We had every intention to be operating right now but now we're
back stuck in the mud," Mr. Brand said. "This extra week, maybe two
with the riots, it's taking a huge financial chunk."
He said he has been trying to rehire more of his former
employers but he has run into a hurdle: Many of his servers and
bartenders have declined offers to come back to work, he said. Some
are fearful of catching the virus; others don't want to give up
their unemployment benefits, which currently pay them more than
they would earn at the restaurant. He believes that as enhanced
unemployment benefits -- the federal payments of $600 a week --
expire, he will have an easier time finding workers.
Economists believe the economy will rebound late this year and
many jobs will be recovered. Forecasting firm Moody's Analytics
projects the unemployment rate will fall to 8.5% by year-end and
that the annual job loss will settle at 8 million.
Bob Tita contributed to this article.
Write to Josh Mitchell at email@example.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
June 06, 2020 09:47 ET (13:47 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.