Daimler warns on profit as Tesla tops VW as second most valuable
By William Boston
This article is being republished as part of our daily
reproduction of WSJ.com articles that also appeared in the U.S.
print edition of The Wall Street Journal (January 23, 2020).
BERLIN -- After decades of churning out huge profits and setting
the standard for premium cars, Germany's top luxury auto makers are
on the retreat, hurt by increased competition, allegations of foul
play and tech-heavy upstarts.
The combination of forces hitting the German premium brands was
on display Wednesday, when Daimler AG -- owner of the Mercedes-Benz
brand -- issued its third profit warning in nine months and said
profits fell nearly 50% last year. In addition, Tesla Inc. overtook
Volkswagen AG as the world's No. 2 most valuable auto maker.
Daimler, Volkswagen and Bayerische Motoren Werke AG continue to
rack up record new car sales, but the auto brands are becoming less
profitable and losing market share in the U.S. and elsewhere.
Germany's premium car makers have been hit by reputational damage
from legal scandals; a global slowdown in vehicle sales; and higher
expenses caused by the cost of investing in electric vehicles.
The beneficiaries are new rivals such as Tesla and recharged
competitors such as Volvo Cars. The German companies are spending
tens of billions of dollars to develop electric vehicles, but they
are playing catch up with Tesla, which is seen as the trendsetter
of the new electric, connected car industry.
"The benchmark today is Tesla," says Ferdinand Dudenhöffer,
director of the Center for Automotive Research at Duisburg-Essen
University. "Ten years from now, Tesla is going to be as big as
The separate legal challenges facing Daimler, BMW, Volkswagen
and Audi AG aren't just tarnishing the image of the companies that
created the premium car brand, but they are also sapping financial
resources each of them needs to invest in new technology. Over the
past three quarters, Daimler has set aside more than $4 billion in
the wake of investigations into allegations that it cheated on
BMW is fighting a ruling by the European Commission, the
European Union's executive arm, that it colluded with other car
makers to fix prices of emissions technology. Last year, the
company took more than $1 billion in charges against earnings for
legal fees in connection with the antitrust action.
In December, BMW said the Securities and Exchange Commission was
investigating its business practices on suspicion that the company
falsified sales figures to show better performance. BMW said it was
cooperating with the SEC but declined to comment on the allegation.
The SEC didn't respond to requests for comment.
Having an even deeper impact on profits is the technology shift
in the industry. Cars are being designed to run on battery power
and to be networked and function more like smartphones on wheels
than simple vehicles to get around town.
"We are valued as an automotive company, but Tesla is valued
like a tech company," Volkswagen CEO Herbert Diess said this month
at a gathering of the company's top executives in Berlin, according
to a transcript of his speech.
Tesla sales in the U.S. have grown 10-fold since 2014, while
Mercedes and BMW have lost market share. Audi sales did soar over
the past five years, but the German brand is in the throes of
restructuring and has barely gained any market share because rivals
such as Tesla, Infiniti and Volvo Cars racked up bigger gains.
Daimler's profit margin from its automotive businesses has
fallen from around 9% in 2013 to an estimated 3% in 2019, lower
than the 4.3% margin forecast for Ford Motor Co., according to data
provided by Evercore ISI, a London-based brokerage.
After years of double-digit profit margins, BMW's margin may
have fallen to as low as 5% in 2019, Evercore said, less than half
the 11% margin the company posted in 2012, the last time it
generated double-digit returns.
Another reason for this loss of luster is that others have
discovered how lucrative a market the German luxury brands' niche
was. Rivals developed their own premium brands and took their
established models upmarket in search of higher profits.
In 2013, Ford Motor Co. revived the long dormant Vignale
subbrand, to compete against Volkswagen. Peugeot breathed new life
into its DS brand. They followed Toyota Motor Co., Nissan Motor
Co., and Honda Motor Co., which had created their respective Lexus,
Infiniti and Acura brands years earlier. Toyota is the most
valuable auto maker, with a market cap of more than $230
One way midmarket makers have raised the luxury content of their
cars has been to pack them with tech. Volvo, nearly extinct until
it was revived with Chinese money after a 2010 takeover by Zhejiang
Geely Holding Group Co., billionaire Li Shufu's company, has come
roaring back with a new fleet of technology-laden premium vehicles.
Still just a third of the size of BMW in terms of sales, Volvo has
teamed up with Alphabet Inc.'s Google to save development costs on
in-car digital technology.
"We now have the products. We are catching up with Audi and BMW.
We have to be seen as an alternative to them," Volvo CEO Hakan
Samuelsson told The Wall Street Journal. "It's about premiumness;
that's how we will grow."
Some threats faced by the German luxury makers aren't limited to
the premium segment.
China, the world's biggest auto market by sales and the largest
market for VW, BMW, and Daimler, declined for the second year in a
row last year. World-wide demand for new cars is softening as the
global economy weakens.
In Europe, profits are coming under renewed pressure across the
car market as companies spend tens of billions of euros to make
electric cars and lower the average carbon-dioxide emissions of
their fleets because of new legislation that threatens them with
billions in penalties if they miss their targets.
Pushed by regulators to lower emissions and spurred on by the
successes of the Tesla generation, the German auto giants have
realized that the times are changing.
"The storm is coming now," Mr. Diess told the VW executives.
"The year 2020 will show whether we're braced for inclement
Write to William Boston at email@example.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
January 23, 2020 02:47 ET (07:47 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Bayerische Motoren Werke (XE:BMW)
Historical Stock Chart
From Jul 2020 to Aug 2020
Bayerische Motoren Werke (XE:BMW)
Historical Stock Chart
From Aug 2019 to Aug 2020