A positive quarter would mark the first time it shows profit in
four straight periods
By Tim Higgins
This article is being republished as part of our daily
reproduction of WSJ.com articles that also appeared in the U.S.
print edition of The Wall Street Journal (July 22, 2020).
After Tesla Inc.'s lone U.S. assembly plant went offline this
spring as authorities in California shut things down to slow the
spread of the coronavirus, many Wall Street analysts doubted the
second quarter would be profitable.
But then the electric-auto maker delivered a surprising number
of new cars and sport-utility vehicles during the three months that
ended on June 30, reporting earlier this month a much smaller
decline than analysts had forecast. The company's shares have
continued to soar since, in part, on increased expectations that
Chief Executive Elon Musk will pull off another Hail Mary
performance and report a profit Wednesday.
"Tesla being profitable has almost become a foregone conclusion
in terms of what's baked into the stock," Dan Ives, an analyst for
Wedbush Securities, said in an interview. "If it's anything other
than that, it would be viewed as a huge negative."
Tesla didn't respond to a request for comment.
A positive earnings report would mark the first time that
17-year-old Tesla has reported four consecutive quarters of profit
and would qualify it for consideration in the S&P 500.
Inclusion in the prestigious benchmark gauge of U.S. equities would
drive index funds to include the company's shares in their
holdings.
The consensus estimate Monday was still for a quarterly loss,
but it has narrowed in recent weeks and would represent a sharp
year-over-year improvement. Analysts surveyed by FactSet, on
average, predict Tesla will lose $228 million in the quarter; on an
adjusted basis, they expect a 14-cent loss per share. In
comparison, analysts were projecting a per-share adjusted loss of
$1.43 in late May, after the company's assembly factory in
California had been shut for several weeks, and the company lost
$408 million in the year-earlier quarter.
In the past five years, four of Tesla's six profitable quarters
have come as surprises to analysts who had predicted losses,
according to FactSet data. The unexpected profit in the third
quarter of last year, for example, helped change the company's
standing among investors, who had grown frustrated with Tesla's
performance in the first half of 2019 over slowing sales and
troubles exporting the Model 3 compact car overseas.
Shares, which had fallen to a low of $176.99 in June 2019,
climbed in the final months of the year, buoyed by the quarter.
That strength has mostly continued, with the stock quadrupling in
2020, amid a string of positive achievements, such as Tesla's
factory in China opening. Shares closed Monday at $1,643.
The company's market value is now more than $300 billion, enough
to overtake Toyota Motor Corp. in recent weeks as the world's most
valuable auto maker.
Tesla said July 2 that it delivered 90,650 vehicles in the
second quarter, a 4.9% decline from the year-earlier quarter that
was much smaller than the 24% drop analysts anticipated because of
the pandemic. The performance was helped by Mr. Musk pushing to
resume California production in early May and the company getting
as many cars delivered in the final weeks of June as possible.
The overall industry hasn't fared as well. Global sales may have
declined 34% in the period, according to an estimate by researcher
LMC Automotive.
Tesla has been helped, in part, by good timing. The company
began production late last year in Shanghai at its first assembly
plant outside of the U.S., giving it capacity to make cars for
important China buyers while its home market struggled with the
impact of the coronavirus.
Because of lower labor costs in Shanghai compared with Tesla's
factory outside of San Francisco in Fremont, Calif., Mr. Ives
estimates that China-made Model 3s are 10% to 15% more profitable
than those made in the U.S. "That's one of the linchpins of the
quarter," he said.
In the U.S., Tesla seems to be helped by the arrival of the
Model Y compact SUV, which began deliveries in March. While Tesla
hasn't broken out results of the Model Y, new vehicle registrations
for 22 states show more than 3,000 of its new SUVs sold during the
period, according to data from researcher Cross-Sell LLC. Data for
all of the states isn't available yet.
Among Mr. Musk's efforts to steer Tesla through the uncertainty
of Covid-19, the company cut salaries, furloughed some workers and
sought rent breaks. Tesla also cut the prices of its vehicles
during the period as it faced rivals using large incentives to
encourage shoppers.
Revenue in the quarter is expected to fall 19% to $5.15 billion,
according to analysts, in part because the average prices of the
vehicles declined. The average selling price of vehicles sold in
the past quarter is estimated at $54,000, compared with almost
$56,000 a year earlier.
Barclays PLC's Brian Johnson is one of the analysts who now
expects Tesla will eke out a profit for the second quarter. He told
investors in a note that the money the company makes from selling
regulatory tax credits, which it gets from the sale of electric
vehicles, could contribute. Those credits helped the company turn a
$16 million profit in the first quarter, when analysts expected a
loss.
Analysts expect 2020 to be the first time Tesla achieves
full-year profit through the end of December, though Mr. Musk's
goal of increasing deliveries by more than 36% this year will be a
challenge because of Covid-19. In April, Tesla backed off from that
forecast, saying it would give an update with second-quarter
results.
Critics point to Tesla lowering prices during the second quarter
and a recent price cut to the Model Y as signs that demand is
loosening. Given Tesla's flexibility in accounting for regulatory
tax credit earnings, short sellers such as David Rocker, a retired
hedge-fund manager, said it shouldn't be surprising if Mr. Musk
shows a profit.
"The real surprise is why Tesla has been steadily cutting prices
on its cars if demand is as strong as it is claimed," he said.
Write to Tim Higgins at Tim.Higgins@WSJ.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
July 22, 2020 02:47 ET (06:47 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Tesla (NASDAQ:TSLA)
Historical Stock Chart
From Feb 2024 to Mar 2024
Tesla (NASDAQ:TSLA)
Historical Stock Chart
From Mar 2023 to Mar 2024