Calm down, SHB. Cat is not a ramper or deramper. He is well known for saying what he thinks. Like everyone else, he is sometimes right and sometimes wrong. Accidents may be rare, but it would be absurd to claim that they cannot and will not happen. If your abusive replies are not emotional, I'd hate to think what emotion can do to you.
I hold HMY and expect it to do well. However, contrary opinions moderately expressed must not be suppressed by angry rampers. A thread exclusively devoted to ramping (like many here) is a useless thread.
Oops, I think I hear a sound on the roof. Happy Christmas all!