Loverat: Paul has had many shares where he's made a major killing - and told us openly at beginning and end. E.g., Xaar, IND, Eyretel, and others too numerous for me to mention. Depending on timing of course - if you bought into FWY at 30p, 40p, 50p etc - then one might be showing a handsome profit now.
What his critics seem to forget is the timing aspect - if you've bought into IND or FWY in recent months you may or may be in profit. And you've also had a bumpy ride but if you DYOR then you or one have no-one to blame or credit but yourself.
So, to my knowledge, Paul has a few go badly (eg Invox) but the good ones outweigh the bad as he said recently and also one should balance the capital allocation against the individual share and it's risk profile.
Are you Fuzebox?