VW Returns to Profit on Absence of Emissions Charges -- 2nd Update
May 31 2016 - 12:13PM
Dow Jones News
By William Boston
BERLIN -- Volkswagen AG swung to a profit in the first three
months of the year, but earnings plunged at its Volkswagen-brand
unit and in China, its biggest single market, demonstrating the
German car maker has far to go in recovering from its
diesel-emissions scandal.
The world's largest car maker by sales is struggling with the
costs of resolving the emissions-cheating affair. The pressure
comes as Volkswagen prepares to unveil in June a strategy review
that is expected to involve restructuring its global brands,
overhauling corporate governance and pushing into electric vehicles
and mobility services.
Volkswagen reported net profit for the quarter through March 31
fell 20%, to EUR2.3 billion ($2.56 billion), compared with the same
quarter a year earlier. The drop was steeper than predicted by
analysts. Unit sales fell 1.2%, to 2.6 million vehicles, and sales
revenue dropped 3.4%, to EUR51 billion.
"We are satisfied overall with the start we have made to what
will undoubtedly be a demanding fiscal year 2016," Chief Executive
Matthias Müller said. "We once again managed to limit the economic
effects of the diesel issue and achieve respectable results under
difficult conditions."
Volkswagen faced a continued sales declines in the U.S. and a
massive sales erosion in Brazil and Russia, but the auto maker said
those markets may be hitting bottom.
In China, its Chinese joint ventures generated an operating
profit of EUR1.2 billion, down 27% from a year ago. Volkswagen has
suffered in China because of a lack of budget models now in high
demand by Chinese consumers.
Overall, the company's operating profit before special items,
which is Volkswagen's main performance metric, fell 6%, to EUR3.1
billion for the first three months of the year. The change
represented a slight decline in the company's operating return on
sales, to 6.1%.
Exchange rates provided some relief. Adjustments to
diesel-related provisions because of changes in the exchange rate
of the dollar against the euro provided a one-time gain of EUR309
million. As a result, Volkswagen's operating profit after special
items rose 3.4% to EUR3.4 billion, a return of 6.8%, beating
analyst forecasts.
Volkswagen reported a record loss of EUR1.6 billion in 2015
after it had to take a charge of EUR16.2 billion against 2015
earnings to cover technical repairs and legal costs related to the
disclosure in September that the company rigged nearly 11 million
diesel engines to cheat on emissions tests. The company didn't take
any new diesel-related provisions in the first three months of
2016.
The company continues to negotiate a final settlement with U.S.
authorities and plaintiffs' attorneys in diesel-related class
action lawsuits representing Volkswagen customers in the U.S. Last
week, the federal judge overseeing the case said the talks were on
track to reach a settlement by June 21.
The diesel-testing scandal has battered Volkswagen's namesake
brand, which has lost market share in major regions of the world
and has had to spend heavily on incentives and loyalty programs to
win back customers.
Operating profit at the Volkswagen brand, which accounts for
half of the company's total revenue, plunged 86%, to EUR73 million,
from the same period a year ago, resulting in a return on sales of
0.3%. That is well below the company's target of a 6% return by
2018.
By comparison, Audi, Volkswagen's luxury car maker, and sports
car brand Porsche continued to hold up Volkswagen profits,
accounting for 70% of the car maker's operating earnings but just
39% of its revenue.
Chronic underperformance of the Volkswagen brand has sparked a
revolt by investors, who have been putting pressure on management
to take drastic action to boost earnings at the division. Investors
say the division is overstaffed and inefficient and needs to cut
jobs in Germany, a move fiercely opposed by labor
representatives.
Frank Witter, Volkswagen's chief finance officer, told investors
on an earnings call that management is well aware that they cannot
blame the diesel crisis for all of the division's troubles.
"It's not just diesel," Mr. Witter said. "The situation is on
our radar and is one of the highest priorities in the
organization."
Write to William Boston at william.boston@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
May 31, 2016 11:58 ET (15:58 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2016 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.