Toshiba Faces Tight Deadline for Restructuring Plan
February 08 2016 - 6:30AM
Dow Jones News
TOKYO—Troubled electronics maker Toshiba Corp. is facing a tight
deadline for mapping out a restructuring plan that has been made
more difficult by the ambiguous role of the Japanese
government.
Sharp Corp. last week made a surprise decision to favor a
takeover offer from Taiwanese electronics assembler Foxconn over a
bailout by a government-led investment fund. That fund, called the
Innovation Network Corp. of Japan, or INCJ, has also been talking
to Toshiba executives, according to people familiar with the
matter, but its inability to land the Sharp deal has made its role
at Toshiba more uncertain.
Toshiba needs a speedy rescue in the wake of an accounting
scandal last year and rapid deterioration of its core units. The
company's share price hit an intraday low of ¥ 167 ($1.42) on
Monday, the lowest level since November 1979, according to data
provider CQG. Toshiba last week projected a ¥ 710 billion loss for
the year ending in March.
On Friday, Standard & Poor's downgraded Toshiba's corporate
credit rating three notches deeper into junk-bond territory. The
ratings agency said Toshiba's short-term borrowing has "jumped
considerably" and "support from main creditor banks will remain
essential to maintain liquidity."
Chief Executive Masashi Muromachi said last week he hoped to
outline key parts of a restructuring plan by the end of February.
The company has said it is looking to sell all or part of units
making medical devices, semiconductors and "white goods" such as
refrigerators and washing machines.
The Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry believes that the de
facto dissolution of Toshiba could be a good opportunity for
consolidating Japanese industry and creating a smaller number of
stronger players, according to people close to the matter. At one
point, the ministry and INCJ, the investment fund that it oversees,
envisioned combining the white-goods businesses of Toshiba and
Sharp, they said.
But Foxconn's plan to take control of Sharp has likely nixed
that plan, because Foxconn, also known as Hon Hai Precision
Industry Co., has said it wants to keep Sharp intact. Toshiba's Mr.
Muromachi said he would consider selling his company's white-goods
unit to a non-Japanese company, with other Asian manufacturers
considered the most likely bidders.
Within the Japanese government, opinions are divided as to
whether it should take the lead in addressing Toshiba's woes.
Japan's Fair Trade Commission said in late January that public
funds shouldn't be involved in bailouts except as a last resort if
the private sector fell short.
Citing the risk of "moral hazard," the commission said, "The
incentive to improve business efficiency is weakened when those
whose operations have fallen into a difficult situation anticipate
that they will be able to receive public aid for revival."
Toshiba's case is more delicate because it has a sizable
nuclear-power business both in Japan and overseas through its
Westinghouse Electric Co. unit, making its fate in part a matter of
national security for Tokyo.
Standard & Poor's said the danger of a liquidity crunch
might ebb if Toshiba can bring in a good price for its
medical-systems business, which makes X-ray machines and other
types of scanners. Toshiba has said it plans to sell a controlling
stake in the profitable business.
People familiar with the sale said it could fetch more than $3
billion. One of those people said the leading bidders include Canon
Inc., Fujifilm Holdings Corp., and a joint effort by Konica Minolta
Inc. and private-equity fund Permira. Canon's chief financial
officer said last month the company was interested in Toshiba's
medical business. Representatives of the other bidders declined to
comment.
Canon, Fujifilm and Konica Minolta, once known as leaders in the
Japanese camera industry, now have significant medical-imaging
businesses. A deal by any of the three would keep Toshiba's
technology under domestic control.
"If the buyer is purely a foreign investment fund which could
make money from selling the business to outsiders, it may not make
much sense for Toshiba and Japanese industry," a government
official said.
Takashi Mochizuki contributed to this article.
Write to Atsuko Fukase at atsuko.fukase@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
February 08, 2016 06:15 ET (11:15 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2016 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.