National Bank of Canada Hit by Maple Bank Probe
February 07 2016 - 8:30PM
Dow Jones News
TORONTO—National Bank of Canada on Sunday warned that its
regulatory-capital level would take a hit after Germany's financial
watchdog BaFin effectively shuttered one of its foreign
investments, the German unit of Maple Financial Group.
Montreal-based National Bank, Canada's sixth-largest bank by
assets, owns a 24.9% stake in Maple Financial Group Inc., which is
the Canadian parent of Germany's Maple Bank GmbH. As a result of
the regulatory action, Maple Bank is effectively closed to customer
transactions.
Consequently, National Bank plans to set aside enough cash to
take a "full reserve" of its equity investment which, at last
check, had a carrying value of 165 million Canadian dollars ($119
million), the bank said.
That means National Bank's CET 1 capital ratio would take a
13-basis-point hit for its fiscal first quarter which ended on Jan
31. The bank's CET 1 capital ratio was 9.9 % at the end of its
fiscal fourth quarter.
National Bank is scheduled to report its fiscal first-quarter
results on Feb. 23.
Maple Bank is under investigation by German prosecutors over
alleged tax irregularities. The focus of the prosecutors' probe,
first disclosed in September 2015, is potential irregularities for
the tax years 2006 to 2010.
For its part, BaFin on Sunday said it issued "a prohibition on
transfer of ownership and payment, due to imminent over
indebtedness. In addition BaFin has ordered the bank to be closed
for dealings with customers."
A Maple spokeswoman in Germany said customer deposits would be
protected in line with the deposit-insurance law. "We ask for your
understanding that we at present can't make any comments about the
further course of the measures," she said.
BaFin said Maple Bank "has no systemic relevance and thus
doesn't pose a threat to financial stability." BaFin said the
bank's balance sheet totaled about 5 billion euros ($5.58
billion).
National Bank noted that German authorities were focusing on
"selected trading activities by Maple Bank, and certain of its
current and former employees" during the specified tax years.
"The German authorities have alleged that these trading
activities violated German tax laws," National Bank said in a news
release on Sunday, adding none of its employees was believed to be
under investigation.
Still, National Bank cautioned that it could be on the hook for
future costs as a result of the tax probe.
"National Bank has advised the German authorities that if it is
determined portions of dividends received from Maple Financial
Group Inc. could be reasonably attributable to tax fraud by Maple
Bank, arrangements will be made to repay those amounts to the
relevant authority," the bank said, noting it didn't expect any
required repayments would be material to its financial results.
In October, National Bank said Maple Financial contributed less
than 1% to its annual net income in each of the last two years.
This isn't the first time, however, that National Bank has seen
its regulatory capital level dented in recent months.
Last fall, National Bank announced fourth-quarter restructuring
charges that were unrelated to its Maple investment, which dented
its CET 1 capital ratio. As a result, the bank undertook a C$300
million common-share offering to plump up its capital base.
"I don't like raising equity," CEO Louis Vachon told investors
at an industry conference last month. "So, I can assure you if we
felt that we have to raise equity, it's really because we felt it
was the right thing to do for the long term," he later added.
The German investigation of Maple Bank "was a surprise," he
said, adding the bank felt compelled to disclose that a substantial
part of its investment could be at risk.
A spokesman for National Bank didn't immediately respond to a
message seeking further comment on Sunday.
Write to Rita Trichur at rita.trichur@wsj.com and Todd Buell at
todd.buell@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
February 07, 2016 20:15 ET (01:15 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2016 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
National Bank of Canada (TSX:NA)
Historical Stock Chart
From Mar 2024 to Apr 2024
National Bank of Canada (TSX:NA)
Historical Stock Chart
From Apr 2023 to Apr 2024