EU to Rule Quickly on European, U.S. Data Pact
September 29 2015 - 8:00AM
Dow Jones News
BRUSSELS—The European Union's highest court on Tuesday confirmed
it would decide early next week on a highly publicized case that
could invalidate a data pact between the EU and the U.S. that is
critical to thousands of businesses.
Judges at the European Court of Justice will deliver their
decision on the morning of Oct. 6, less than two weeks after an
adviser to the court published a non-binding recommendation that
the so-called Safe Harbor agreement should be scrapped.
A court decision invalidating Safe Harbor risks wreaking havoc
on the large numbers of companies using the framework to transfer
data for everything from payroll information to company phone
books.
The 15-year-old trans-Atlantic deal allows firms, such as
Facebook Inc. and Yelp Inc., to store Europeans' data in the U.
S.—as long as the companies agree to comply with Europe's stricter
privacy laws.
Yves Bot, an advocate general to the ECJ, said last week the
deal should be nullified because Europeans' data is unprotected in
the U.S., where intelligence services engage in mass
surveillance.
The decision to move ahead so rapidly with the announcement of
the judgment suggests the court is aware of the importance of the
ruling for a large number of businesses.
"Whilst it is possible…it's not normal to only take two weeks
from opinion to decision," said Christopher Fretwell, a spokesman
for the ECJ.
On average, it takes between three and six months from a court
adviser's opinion until a decision is published, according to Mr.
Fretwell. That is largely because the documents need to be
translated into the EU's 24 official languages.
But he said it is possible to speed up that process, especially
if judges decide to prioritize the case, or if much of the text is
already translated —for example, if the judges replicate large
parts of the advocate general's opinion as fact.
The U.S. this week criticized Mr. Bot for basing his opinion on
"inaccurate assertions" about U.S. intelligence practices. The U.S.
mission to the EU rejected the accusation of mass surveillance,
claiming that the National Security Agency program Prism, which Mr.
Bot alluded to, focuses on specific foreign-intelligence
targets.
The timing of the court's decision is awkward as Washington and
Brussels have been working for almost two years to update the
agreement, which was called into question following revelations in
2013 of widespread U.S. spying.
Despite the opinion, both U.S. and EU officials say they want to
update the deal, which is still being negotiated and should
conclude soon. But it is unclear now whether that would come before
the court's decision on Tuesday or afterwards.
Write to Natalia Drozdiak at natalia.drozdiak@wsj.com
Subscribe to WSJ: http://online.wsj.com?mod=djnwires
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
September 29, 2015 07:45 ET (11:45 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2015 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Meta Platforms (NASDAQ:META)
Historical Stock Chart
From Mar 2024 to Apr 2024
Meta Platforms (NASDAQ:META)
Historical Stock Chart
From Apr 2023 to Apr 2024