ADVFN - Advanced Financial Network.
HOME» NASDAQ » T » TIVO Stock Price » TIVO Stock News

Tivo Share News

 Tivo Inc. (mm) Stock Price
TIVO Stock Price
 Tivo Inc. (mm) Stock Chart
TIVO Stock Chart
 Tivo Inc. (mm) Stock News
TIVO Stock News
 Tivo Inc. (mm) Company Information
TIVO Company Information
 Tivo Inc. (mm) Stock Trades
TIVO Stock Trades

US Appeals Court Again Considers TiVo-Dish DVR Case

By Brent Kendall Of DOW JONES NEWSWIRES WASHINGTON -(Dow Jones)- A federal appeals court on Tuesday grappled with a high-stakes patent dispute between TiVo Inc. (TIVO) and sister companies Dish Network Corp. (DISH) and EchoStar Corp. (SATS) over digital video recorders. At issue was a trial judge's decision to hold Dish and EchoStar in contempt last year for violating an injunction barring them from making or selling DVRs that infringed a TiVo patent on the technology, which allows viewers to pause and record live television. During oral arguments Tuesday, a lawyer for EchoStar and Dish said the companies shouldn't have been held in contempt because they attempted in good faith to design new technology that was different from their previous devices that were found to infringe TiVo's patent. "EchoStar removed the very features that TiVo accused of infringement," company lawyer Joshua Rosenkranz said. TiVo's lawyer, Seth Waxman, said EchoStar and Dish violated the injunction because their newer DVR devices weren't that different from previous ones that violated TiVo's intellectual property. The companies "disregarded every provision of the injunction," Waxman said. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is hearing the contempt case for a second time. In March, a three-judge panel of the court sided with TiVo in a 2-1 ruling, which would have cleared the way for the company to collect about $300 million from Dish and EchoStar. That decision sent TiVo's shares surging more than 60%. But in May, the appeals court withdrew its ruling for TiVo and said a larger panel of judges would reconsider the case, a move that sent TiVo's shares down more than 40%. A win for TiVo could help the company in other related litigation. Nine judges participated in Tuesday's oral argument. The likely outcome wasn't clear from the proceedings, but TiVo did face tough questions from some judges. Two judges, Timothy Dyk and Kimberly Moore, appeared to question the fairness of scrutinizing EchoStar and Dish's redesigned DVR devices in contempt proceedings. They questioned whether the matter should have been resolved instead through new patent infringement proceedings. Chief Judge Randall Rader previously voiced the same concerns when he dissented in the earlier ruling against the two companies. Judge Sharon Prost questioned whether the injunction against Dish and EchoStar was too broad or ambiguous. Dish and EchoStar also faced some tough questions. Judge Arthur Gajarsa, for example, questioned why the companies didn't challenge the trial judge's injunction earlier. The case dates to 2004 when TiVo sued Dish alleging that it made DVRs that TiVo claimed infringed on one of its patents. A jury in 2006 found Dish and EchoStar liable for infringing TiVo's DVR patent when they began making their own set-top boxes that could pause and record live television. A federal judge imposed contempt sanctions last year after finding that a technological redesign developed by EchoStar and Dish still infringed TiVo's patent. The case is TiVo v. EchoStar, 2009-1374. -By Brent Kendall, Dow Jones Newswires; 202-862-9222;

Stock News for Tivo (TIVO)
03/25/201516:55:30Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4)
03/20/201517:14:58Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4)
03/19/201516:18:34Annual Report (10-k)
03/17/201518:38:59Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4)
03/17/201518:38:29Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4)
03/17/201518:37:29Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4)
03/17/201518:36:44Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4)
03/17/201518:35:44Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4)
03/17/201518:34:43Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4)
03/11/201520:34:45TiVo: 1.5M cord-cutters in the wings amid mass dissatisfaction
03/11/201517:15:13Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4)
03/10/201516:38:24Aereo Accuses Broadcasters of Chilling Bidding in Asset Sale
03/06/201506:48:03Where could HBO Now go? (And where does it leave HBO Go now?)
03/04/201518:35:15Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4)
03/04/201511:45:45MARKET SNAPSHOT: U.S. Stocks Slump After Private-sector Jobs...
03/04/201511:44:01MARKET SNAPSHOT: U.S. Stocks Slump After Private-sector Jobs...
03/04/201511:42:35MARKET SNAPSHOT: U.S. Stocks Slump After ADP Report Nearly Meets...
03/04/201510:26:25MARKET SNAPSHOT: U.S. Stocks Slump After ADP Report Nearly Meets...
03/04/201509:24:16MARKET SNAPSHOT: U.S. Stock Futures Under Pressure; Private-sector...
03/04/201508:55:09MARKET SNAPSHOT: U.S. Stocks Futures Under Pressure; Private-sector...

Tivo and other NASDAQ stock quotes are delayed by at least 20 minutes.
All other stock price and quote data is delayed by at least 15 minutes unless otherwise stated. By accessing the services available at ADVFN you are agreeing to be bound by ADVFN's Terms & Conditions
Contact Us | Copyright 1999-2007 ADVFN PLC. | Privacy Policy | Investment Warning | Data accreditations | Investor Relations